Pants or Shorts for Hiking - Which Is Really Best?

Deciding between pants or shorts for hiking can be confusing if you don't have a lot of experience yet. A lot of it depends on not just climate, weather, terrain, but also personal preference. There are hikers that swear by wearing pants for extra protection, and those who prefer the freedom of shorts.

So which is right for you, pants or shorts? Let's find out.

The Case for Pants

The main advantage of hiking in pants over shorts is for added protection. Depending on where you're hiking, this can be important.

And when I say protection, I mean protection from:

• Ticks
• Scrapes and punctures
• Poison ivy/oak
• Debris and dirt
• Snakes, spiders, and other crawlers

Ticks are a huge reason hikers like to wear pants. Here in New England, ticks can carry Lyme Disease. Those infected can have symptoms of fatigue, pain, muscle aches lasting for months. A common preventative measure is wearing pants that are tucked into your socks.

Poison ivy and oak are another potential concern. If you're staying on well-groomed trails and not bushwacking, this might not be a huge problem. Here in New Hampshire, I've personally never had poison ivy except for once when staying at a campground. However, poison ivy thrives on warmer weather. Some people describe trails down south as "jungles" where bugs and poison ivy are everywhere.

Another reason to wear pants on the trail are bugs. Sometime's there's no avoiding them. As someone who prefers to wear shorts, I've gotten a lot of mosquito bites during my hikes. It's not too much much of a problem when hiking, but stopping to rest is.

If you're doing any kind of bushwacking or rough climbing, pants have a clear advantage. Pants will help protect you against thorns, branches, and sharp rocks. Pants will also keep you clean. After a good 9 mile hike, I often hop in the shower and see all the dirt that comes off me.

In some climates, you may come across snakes, spiders, and other crawlers. In any type of harsher environment, pans are the winner.

Here's why some prefer pants:

During the peak of tick season, I hike in pants even if it’s boiling hot. It also helps keep debris out of your shoes.

Always pants with the cuffs tucked into your long socks.

Pants for me...better protection against bugs, snakes, plants.

You may also like Best Ultralight Down Jackets

The Case for Shorts

I personally prefer shorts. I like feeling comfortable and don't mind getting a little dirty. There are some hikers who wear shorting hiking the entire Appalachian trail, so it's certainly part personal preference.

In fact, many thru-hikers on the Appalachian trail often wear the most minimalist clothing they can get away with. It's not uncommon for many of these hikers to hike without underwear.

The main advantage of wearing shorts is comfort. Many climates are hot and humid, and pants just make everything worse. Many experienced hikers wear running shorts or lightweight synthetic shirts.

There's always the question of, "what if it rains or gets cold?". A lot of times, that generally isn't a problem. I'm not one of those crazy people that wear shorts in the dead winter during a snowstorm, but there's is some truth to this. Most of your body heat is generated from your core. If you keep your core warm, the rest of your body will stay much warmer. And while your legs are moving, they are generating their own heat.

As far as rain, as long as it's not cold, it's not a problem either. Having wet legs is just that, wet legs. A little rain is perfectly fine. I actually feel more comfortable in shorts than pants when it does rain.

The downside of wearing shorts is when you stop moving, it can feel cold, especially when you are at high altitude with high winds. In such environments, it does make sense to have some extra protection around the legs.

For protection, shorts aren't always the best against bugs, scrapes, and sunburns. While you might not like the look, wearing tights under your shorts is one option. This allows for a lot of freedom of movement and is lightweight.

Anytime I do ultra-marathons or multi-day adventure races, I like to wear rights under my running shorts.

Here's what some other hikers had to say:

Shorts, always. I don't mind yoga pants in the winter, but for some reason, they are uncomfortable with the slightest bit of warmth in the air. Oddly, I don't have the same issue when I run. Hiking pants are not only uncomfortable, but they are also unflattering.

Shorts & bug repellent. My legs do get banged up on occasion, but it’s worth it for them to be free.

Nylon Under Armor athletic shorts for hiking. I've had three pair for 15 years. They never wear out. Long workout pants for the evening.

Something Else?

If you still can't decide between pants and shorts for hiking, there are other options too. Many people were convertible or zip-off pants. I have a pair myself that I quite like. These pants, in particular, come with a built-in belt, are lightweight, and quick drying. I actually wear them in the winter over my insulated rights.

Women also hike in yoga pants and leggings. There are even leggings designed for hiking with pocket room and built-in bug repellent.

Hiking in skirts or kilts is another option. These are probably the most comfortable, especially if you are a hot hiker and sweat a lot.

You may also like What to Wear While Camping With Your Boyfriend

Weather Considerations

We've covered a lot when it comes to pants vs shorts for hiking. One thing to keep in mind is the material you will be wearing. As you may have heard, cotton kills. There are people who wear jeans in hiking, and it can work, but you can't get them wet. The same thing goes for hiking in sweatpants. These are okay for shorter hikes and nature walks, but nothing beyond that.

Whicher ever attire you wear hiking, the important thing is that it's safe first, comfortable second.

Temperature-Based Rule of Thumb

The cleanest way to decide is temperature plus exposure. Rough guide:

• Above 75°F: shorts. Full stop.
• 65°F to 75°F: shorts for most people, pants if you're in brushy or buggy terrain.
• 50°F to 65°F: convertible pants, or shorts with a lightweight pant layer in your pack.
• 40°F to 50°F: pants. Shorts only if you're moving hard and generating heat.
• Below 40°F: pants, always. Layer base + pants for cold weather.

Wind changes the math fast. 60°F with 20 mph wind feels like 45°F — pants territory. Altitude changes it too — it's typically 3–5°F colder per 1,000 feet of climb.

When Pants Are Obvious

• Ticks or chiggers. Pants tucked into socks = the single most effective tick-bite prevention. No amount of DEET beats a physical barrier.
• Poison oak, ivy, sumac. Skin contact is how the rash starts. Pants are the only reliable prevention.
• Bushwhacking. Thorns, brambles, scree. Pants protect shins and calves.
• Sun protection above treeline. At altitude, UV is 30% stronger. Long pants beat sunscreen you'll forget to reapply.
• Snow, rain, cold. No debate — pants.
• River crossings deeper than knee-high. Convertible pants with the legs zipped off become shorts; zipped on, they protect against cold water.

When Shorts Are Obvious

• Hot humid weather. Sweat evaporates. Nothing wicks heat like bare legs.
• Long flat trails. Ranger-maintained trails with no off-path exposure. Ticks are rare on well-mowed paths.
• Water-heavy hikes. Swimming holes, waterfalls, swamps. Shorts dry fast; wet pants are miserable.
• Running-pace trail use. Trail running in pants overheats you fast.
• Well-known trails in mosquito season — no joke. Counter-intuitive, but bug spray on legs is easier than mosquitoes biting through thin pants.

Convertible Pants: The Middle Ground

Convertible (zip-off) pants are the single best compromise. What to look for:

• Color-coded zippers. Makes putting the legs back on in the right orientation easier.
• Two zippers per leg. Most reliable design. One-zipper legs can flap open.
• Shorts zip at mid-thigh. Inseam at 7" becomes shorts when zipped off.
• Mesh inner brief (optional). Built-in underwear makes them dual-use for water crossings.
• Hidden zippered pockets. Keep your phone and keys safe during leg swap.

Good picks: Columbia Silver Ridge Convertible, Outdoor Research Ferrosi Convertible, Marmot Scree Convertible. Not fashion, but hugely practical.

Fabric Matters More Than Length

Whatever you pick, the fabric matters more than whether they cover your knees:

• Nylon or nylon blends. Water-resistant, tear-resistant, fast-drying. The standard for hiking.
• Polyester blends. Faster-drying than nylon but less abrasion-resistant.
• Softshell. Warm, wind-resistant, water-repellent. Ideal for shoulder seasons.
• Denim. Tough but slow-drying. See our hiking in jeans breakdown.
• Cotton. Avoid. Holds sweat, chafes, takes forever to dry.

Leggings, Joggers and the Rest

• Hiking leggings. Popular, functional, and great for cool-weather day hikes. Lack pocket space; pair with a hip belt.
• Joggers / sweatpants. Comfortable, casual. See our joggers for hiking piece.
• Running shorts with liner. Ideal for summer hiking. Saves you bringing separate underwear.
• Kilts (Utilikilt, Mountain Hardwear Elkommando). Yes, people hike in them. Great ventilation, unusual looks, love-it-or-hate-it.

Pants vs Shorts FAQ

Are hiking shorts better than regular shorts?

Yes — hiking-specific shorts have articulated knees, built-in liners, moisture-wicking fabric, and deeper pockets. Regular basketball or gym shorts work but less well over long distances.

Should I wear pants in summer to prevent ticks?

In high-tick areas, yes — treated pants tucked into socks are far more effective than DEET on bare legs. Pretreated Insect Shield clothing (permethrin-infused) adds another layer of protection.

What do thru-hikers wear — pants or shorts?

Mostly shorts in summer sections, zip-off pants for variable weather, full pants for winter or desert sections. Most thru-hikers carry one of each and swap by section.

Can I hike in yoga pants?

Yes, but they're optimized for studios, not trails. Hiking-specific leggings (Prana, Athleta Trekkie, Outdoor Research) use more durable fabric and have pockets.

Are shorts OK in cold weather if I move fast?

Experienced hikers do this down to ~40°F by generating body heat. It's fine on a climb; it can become dangerous the moment you stop moving. Always have a pants option in your pack for cold weather.