Which Colorado Fourteener Should Be Your First?

By Jake Reyes · April 26, 2026 · 9 min read
Snow-dusted pyramid-shaped Colorado peak rising above dark forested slopes under a partly cloudy sky
Photo by Devon Barhaug on pexels

Picking the right Colorado Fourteener for a first attempt matters more than most people expect. We've been up enough of them to know how to break someone in, and the honest first-time picks are below, along with the reasoning behind them and the peaks we'd steer you away from.

A fourteener is simply a mountain whose summit sits above the fourteen-thousand-foot mark, and Colorado has plenty of them. If you want the background on the term, the Wikipedia entry on fourteeners is a decent primer. What it can't tell you is which one suits a person who has never felt thin air in their lungs.

How to choose your first Colorado Fourteener

Three things decide whether a first fourteener goes well: the difficulty class of the route, the sustained effort involved, and how many other people are around if something goes wrong. Everything else, including views, is a bonus.

Difficulty class is the shorthand hikers use for terrain. Class 2 means you're on a trail or rough ground and may use your hands now and then for balance, but you aren't climbing. Class 4 is a different sport entirely, with exposed moves where a slip has serious consequences. For a first summit you want the low end of that scale, and you want it for the whole route, not just the first half.

Sustained effort is the quieter factor. Distance and elevation gain tell you how long you'll be working, but altitude changes how hard the same effort feels. A climb that would be a routine day at sea level can leave a first-timer short of breath, headachy and slow. That's normal. It's also why we pick routes with a clear path, a manageable number of miles and a trailhead that doesn't require a punishing approach.

Then there's company. A busy trail is not a flaw on a first fourteener. It means the route is obvious, help is within shouting distance, and you can watch how experienced people pace themselves.

Mt Bierstadt: the right answer for most people

The numbers are 14,065 ft, 7 miles round trip, and 2,850 ft of gain. The route is Class 2 the whole way, so there's no real scrambling. The trailhead is paved, which sounds trivial until you've watched someone's low-clearance car struggle on a washboard road before dawn.

The Sawtooth ridge is the showpiece of this area, and it's genuinely impressive. The standard route doesn't touch it, though. You look at it, you photograph it, and you stay on the easier ground. Some people feel cheated by that, but we'd argue it's the right trade for a first summit. The ridge is for later, if you ever want it.

You'll see 200 other people on a Saturday in July, which is the right number for your first time. There's a margin of safety in numbers when you're still figuring out what altitude feels like. If you start to struggle, someone will notice, and if you lose the path, you can follow the crowd. Solitude is lovely, but it's a luxury for people who already know how their body behaves up high.

If you'd like the route details laid out in one place, our Mount Bierstadt trail page covers them. The practical point is that this is a forgiving mountain. It rewards steady pacing and punishes only the people who start late or ignore the sky.

Quandary Peak: better for fitness training

Quandary comes in at 14,265 ft, 6.7 miles, and 3,450 ft of gain. The east ridge is the standard route. Notice what those figures say compared with Bierstadt: more elevation gain in less distance. That means the trail is steeper on average, and steep ground is where your legs and lungs find out what they're made of.

The scrambling here is easier than on some peaks but more sustained. In practice that means you'll use your hands occasionally and need to pay attention to footing for longer stretches. It isn't technical, but it asks you to stay switched on rather than settle into a rhythm and daydream.

We send people here who've done Bierstadt and want to know what a slightly bigger day feels like. That's the right way to think about it. A second fourteener should stretch you a little, not a lot. Stepping from a gentle first outing to a harder second one teaches you about pacing, food and water, and how your body responds to a steeper grade, all without putting you in over your head.

One honest caveat: because the gain is packed into fewer miles, the descent can be hard on knees. Controlled, shorter steps help, and so does a pair of poles. If you're weighing that choice, our piece on whether to use one trekking pole or two walks through the trade-offs.

Mt Sherman: the budget option

Sherman is 14,036 ft, 4.2 miles, and 2,100 ft of gain. Take the high trailhead and it's the shortest fourteener in the state. For someone short on time, energy or confidence, that's a real attraction, and it explains why the mountain gets so many first-timers.

It's also the least scenic of the three. Expect old mining ruins and sage scree rather than dramatic ridgelines. Scree is loose broken rock, and it can be tiring because each step slides back a little. It isn't dangerous on this kind of terrain, but it does sap energy, and a short hike can feel longer than the mileage suggests.

Some people's first fourteener is Sherman, and there's nothing wrong with that. We just don't personally love it, and I'd rather you save your first summit for a mountain that makes you want a second one. A first fourteener is partly an audition. If the scenery is dull, some people decide the whole pursuit isn't for them, which would be a shame.

The sensible way to use Sherman is as a low-pressure choice when conditions or schedules rule out the others. It's a legitimate summit, and the altitude is the same regardless of how short the walk is.

What we don't recommend as a first

A couloir is a steep, narrow gully. Depending on the season it can hold snow or ice, and it funnels rockfall and falling climbers straight down the line you're standing in. Route names are usually honest, so if the word is in the title, treat it as a warning and not a selling point.

Maroon Peak shows why a pretty mountain can be a poor teacher. Rotten rock is loose, crumbling stone that breaks off when you grab it or step on it. On Class 4 terrain, where you're relying on handholds, that's a serious hazard. Admire it from below.

The San Juans are a separate problem. The mountains themselves aren't the issue; the logistics are. Long drives to trailheads mean tired starts, and a tired driver at dawn is the first mistake in a chain of small ones. Build experience on mountains close to services before you commit to a remote range.

The non-negotiable advice

Sleep two nights above 7,000 ft before your attempt. Start at the trailhead by 5am. Afternoon thunderstorms above treeline are not a metaphor. Turn around at noon if you're not on top, no matter how close you feel.

Why two nights up high matters

Your body adapts to altitude gradually, and sleeping at elevation is a big part of that. Arriving from low ground and heading straight up invites headaches, nausea and exhaustion, which are the early signs of altitude sickness. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention publishes travel health guidance on altitude illness, and it's worth reading before your first trip. If you need a base, our guide to mountain camping in Colorado covers elevation picks that suit this plan, and camping also puts you closer to an early start.

Why the early start and the noon rule exist

Summer storms in the high country build in the afternoon. Above treeline there's nowhere to shelter, and you are the tallest object on an open slope. Lightning is the danger, not the rain. Check the mountain forecast from the National Weather Service before you leave, and treat clouds building before midday as a reason to descend, not a reason to hurry upward.

The noon turnaround is a rule for a reason. Summit fever is real, and it makes ordinary people badly misjudge how close they are. Deciding the cutoff at the trailhead, when your head is clear, removes the argument you'd otherwise have with yourself at eleven fifty on a tired slope. Turning back isn't failure. The mountain will still be there.

Small habits that make a first summit easier

Pack layers even on a hot morning, because temperature drops and wind picks up fast on the upper slopes. Carry more water than seems sensible, eat small amounts regularly rather than waiting until you're hungry, and wear sunscreen, since the sun is strong at height. Blisters can end a long day early, so it's worth reading about wearing two pairs of socks when hiking before you lace up.

Pace yourself so you can still talk in short sentences. If you can't, slow down. Most first-timers go out too fast in the opening miles and pay for it above treeline. Keep your breaks short but regular, and pay attention to headaches that don't ease with water and rest.

Plan the trip around the season too. High routes are best when snow has cleared from the trail, so check our notes on when camping season starts and how to time a mountain trip. If you're stretching the outing into a weekend, how long a camping trip should be is worth a look.

Finally, leave the mountain as you found it. Pack out everything, stay on the established path to protect fragile alpine plants, and follow the Leave No Trace principles. Crowded peaks suffer when even a few people cut corners, and Bierstadt on a July Saturday is proof of how many boots a single trail has to absorb.

So start with Bierstadt, move to Quandary when you want more, and keep Sherman in your pocket for a short day. Then go home, rest, and ask yourself whether you're ready for the next one.

Tagged

Common questions

How fit do I need to be to climb Mt Bierstadt?
If you can comfortably hike 7 miles with 2,850 ft of gain at low elevation, you can probably finish Bierstadt — it'll just take longer than you expect because of the altitude. Plan on 5-7 hours round trip and don't be surprised if your pace drops to under a mile an hour above 13,500 ft.
Do I need to acclimatize before climbing my first fourteener?
Yes. We tell everyone to sleep two nights above 7,000 ft before the attempt — staying in Denver doesn't count, since it's only around 5,300 ft. Leadville, Breckenridge, or any Front Range mountain town works.
When is the best time of year to hike Bierstadt or Quandary?
Mid-July through mid-September is the standard window for snow-free Class 2 conditions. June can still have lingering snowfields above 13,000 ft, and by late September you're gambling on early storms. July weekdays give you the best balance of conditions and crowd size.
What time should I start a fourteener hike?
On the trailhead by 5am, moving by first light. Afternoon thunderstorms build fast above treeline in summer, and the rule we don't break is: turn around at noon if you're not on the summit, regardless of how close it looks.
Is Mt Sherman a good first fourteener?
It's the easiest one statistically — 4.2 miles and 2,100 ft of gain from the upper trailhead — and some people start there. We'd rather send a first-timer up Bierstadt because Sherman's old mining slopes and loose scree aren't a great introduction to what fourteeners actually feel like.
Can I do Quandary Peak as my first fourteener if I'm in good shape?
You can, and plenty of fit people do. Just know it's about 600 more feet of gain than Bierstadt in less distance, with some easy scrambling on the east ridge — manageable, but it punishes a slow acclimatization more than Bierstadt does.
What gear do I actually need for a Class 2 fourteener in summer?
Trail runners or light hikers, 2-3 liters of water, a wind shell and an insulated layer (summit temps can be 30-40°F colder than the trailhead), sun protection, and a headlamp for the pre-dawn start. Trekking poles help on the descent more than most people expect.
About the author
Jake Reyes
Jake Reyes
Lead gear tester · Bishop, California

Jake spent his twenties guiding raft trips and rock climbing in the Eastern Sierra and now leads our gear-testing program. If a piece has been on a Pack Your Tent gear list, odds are Jake has carried it for 50+ miles or chopped wood with it in 20-degree sleet.

Wilderness First Responder. Ten seasons guiding for OARS in the Sierra Nevada. AMGA Single-Pitch Instructor cert.

More from Jake Reyes